Alternatives to Halloween candy

25 non-food Halloween treats, sorted by age

Handing out something other than sweets solves three real problems at the door: children with food allergies can take part, you're not adding to a bucket that's already overflowing, and you avoid the small hard sweets that are risky for the youngest trick-or-treaters.

What it doesn't do is make Halloween "healthy". A plastic spider ring isn't nutritious — it's just not food. The honest case for non-food treats is inclusion, variety and volume, not health.

First, the two things that decide what's safe

You can't tell a child's age at the door

A four-year-old and an eight-year-old arrive in the same costume, in the same group, holding out the same bucket. This is the practical problem with any age-sorted list.

Two ways round it:

Two bowls. One holding only items safe for the youngest visitors, one with everything else. Ask "how old are you?" or read the height of the child rather than the parent's answer.
One bowl, lowest common denominator. Everything in it is safe for a toddler. Simpler, and it's what most people end up doing.

Small parts, latex, batteries

Before buying anything in bulk, check for four things:

Check	Why
Small parts	Anything that fits through a toilet-roll tube is a choking risk for under-threes. The FDA names gum and small toys specifically as Halloween choking hazards for young children. FDA Halloween food-safety advice
Latex	Latex allergy is not rare, and balloons are the item most often involved. Balloons — inflated or not — shouldn't go in the bowl at all
Button batteries	Light-up rings and mini torches often use coin cells. Swallowed, they cause serious internal injury quickly. Skip anything battery-powered unless the compartment is screwed shut
The age label	"Not suitable for children under 3" is on the packet for a reason. Multipacks of party-bag fillers carry it constantly

Safe for any age, including under 3

Large enough that they can't be swallowed, no latex, no batteries.

Chunky wax crayons — the fat toddler kind, sold singly or in twos
Sticker sheets — pumpkins, bats, ghosts; universally popular and the cheapest thing on this list
Temporary tattoos — check for a non-latex adhesive if you can
Mini playdough pots — the small party-bag size, around 20g
Full-size card masks — flat, big, no elastic small parts

Roughly 3 to 5

Bubble wands — the small bottles; expect them to be opened on the pavement
Glow bracelets — the liquid inside is a mild irritant if the tube splits, so these are for children old enough not to chew them
Chunky pavement chalk
Self-inking stamps — pumpkin and bat shapes
Mini colouring books
Halloween-print socks — sounds dull, gets a better reaction than you'd expect

Roughly 6 to 9

Spider rings — the classic, and genuinely too small for a toddler
Novelty erasers
Bouncy balls — small balls are a choking hazard for young children; fine at this age
Sticker albums or collectable-style sticker packs
Mini notebooks
Pencil toppers
Putty or slime pots — check the label if anyone in the house has a wheat allergy, as some contain wheat starch
Bookmarks
Glow-in-the-dark wall stars

Roughly 10 and up

Gel pens — metallic and glitter ones
Keyrings and bag charms
Fidget toys
Mini card games or puzzle cubes
Face paint sticks or hair chalk — check for a patch-test instruction on the packet

Leave these out

Balloons. Latex, and the single most common choking hazard among children's items.
Gum. Named by the FDA as a Halloween choking hazard for young children.
Anything with a loose button battery.
Whistles, kazoos and anything mouth-blown. Shared mouth items, and parents will not thank you.
Very small figures, beads and jacks unless you're certain of the age of the child taking them.

Teeth, honestly

Sweets aren't straightforwardly "bad for your teeth". What raises the risk of tooth decay is how often teeth are exposed to sugar, rather than the total amount of sweets eaten in a year. Every sugar exposure starts a period of acid attack on the enamel; a bucket grazed on for three weeks may do more damage than the same sweets eaten across two or three sittings.

The practical version for Halloween night: sweets with a meal, or in a short sitting, then brush. Rationing one sweet a day for a month is a pattern more likely to cause problems, even though it feels like the moderate option.

Non-food treats help here simply by reducing how much sugar comes through the door in the first place.

Including children with allergies

A child with a serious food allergy usually can't accept most of what's handed out, and often can't tell from the wrapper. Non-food treats are the one thing they can take without checking.

If you want to signal that you have non-food options, the Teal Pumpkin Project — a teal-painted pumpkin or a printed sign by the door — is the widely recognised way to do it. Keep the non-food items in a separate bowl, or they end up mixed in with the wrappers and defeat the point.

What it costs

Non-food treats are usually more expensive per item than a bag of fun-size chocolate. Ways to keep it reasonable:

Buy party-bag multipacks in September rather than the week before
Stickers, tattoos and crayons come out cheapest per child
Work out your budget per child, not per pack — a hundred visitors at 20p is £20
Mixing is fine. Nobody expects the whole bowl to be non-food

Lower-waste options

Most of this list is small plastic that lasts one evening. If that bothers you:

Paper-based: stickers, tattoos, bookmarks, colouring books, card masks
Usable: pencils, crayons, chalk, erasers, notebooks — things that get used up rather than thrown out
Skip the individual wrapping where you can; loose items in a bowl work fine
Avoid the multipacks of tiny mixed plastic toys, which are the worst of both worlds on cost and waste

Or make something instead

If you'd rather put the effort into food than into plastic, the treats children remember are usually the ones they helped make:

Cook next: Halloween party food kids can make - Roasted pumpkin seeds - How to carve a pumpkin safely with kids - Halloween pumpkin picking

Search